Real estate tax concepts for physicians

Depreciation, passive losses, what happens at sale, and retirement accounts, explained by a physician investor. Concepts, not tax advice.

Physicians pay among the highest marginal rates in the country, and most of what we earn is ordinary income. Real estate is one of the few places where the tax code treats an investor differently. This page explains the concepts I think a physician should understand before investing passively in apartments. It describes how the rules generally work. It is not tax advice, and your CPA is the person who applies it to you.

Depreciation

The IRS treats a residential building as wearing out over 27.5 years, even while the property may be rising in value. Each year, a slice of the building's cost (never the land) is deducted as depreciation. It is a non-cash expense: nobody writes a check for it.

In a syndication, that deduction passes through to you on a Schedule K-1 in proportion to your share. It can offset the rental income behind your distributions, so cash you receive may be partly or fully tax-deferred in the year you receive it. A cost segregation study, done by engineers, identifies parts of the property (appliances, flooring, parking lots, landscaping) that can be depreciated over 5, 7 or 15 years instead of 27.5, which moves deductions earlier. How much of that can be taken in the first year depends on the bonus-depreciation rules in effect for the year the property was bought, which Congress has changed several times; ask your CPA what applies to a given deal.

Passive losses and your clinical income

For most physicians, a syndication is a passive activity. Passive losses generally offset only passive income, such as income from other passive real estate investments. They do not offset your W-2 or practice income. Losses you cannot use are not wasted: they carry forward year to year and are generally released when you sell or fully dispose of your interest.

The main exception is Real Estate Professional status. Most practicing physicians will not qualify, because it requires more than half of your working hours, and at least 750 hours a year, in real estate businesses. A spouse who qualifies, or a physician who has substantially reduced clinical hours, can change the math materially. Talk to your CPA before you invest, not after.

What happens at sale

Depreciation defers tax; it does not erase it. When the property is sold, the depreciation you took is generally "recaptured": on the building, at a federal rate of up to 25%, and on the shorter-lived items a cost segregation study accelerated, at ordinary-income rates. Gain above that is generally long-term capital gain, taxed at a top federal rate of 20% rather than the 37% top rate on ordinary income. For high earners, the 3.8% net investment income tax applies to both, and most states tax the gain as well.

A 1031 exchange can defer that tax by rolling the proceeds into another property, but in a syndication the decision is made at the property level by the sponsor, and most syndications simply sell and distribute the proceeds. An individual investor generally cannot 1031 a partnership interest on their own. If a 1031 matters to you, ask the sponsor about it before you invest.

Retirement accounts

Self-directed IRAs and Solo 401(k)s can hold syndication interests, which lets you invest pre-tax or Roth dollars in real assets. Two things change inside a retirement account. First, depreciation does nothing for you, because the account already pays no current tax. Second, the debt used to buy the property can create Unrelated Business Taxable Income (UBTI), which can be taxed inside the account. Solo 401(k)s have an exception for some debt-financed real estate that IRAs do not, but whether it applies depends on how the specific deal is structured. Many, but not all, deals are structured to fit it. Check with your sponsor and verify with your tax professional. My Solo 401(k) article covers who can open one.

The paperwork

Each syndication sends a Schedule K-1, often later than the 1099s from a brokerage account, and many physicians file an extension as a result. A property in another state can also mean a state return there. Neither is a reason to avoid the investment, but both belong in the conversation with your CPA.

How this compares

REITs and interval funds handle depreciation differently, and that difference is most of why a syndication tends to be the most tax-efficient of the three in a taxable account. I compare them, with a calculator, in syndications vs. REITs vs. interval funds. Before choosing a specific deal, read how physicians evaluate a multifamily syndication.

Federal rates and thresholds described here are general and as of the date above. Tax law changes, and outcomes vary by investor. Nothing here is tax advice; confirm how any of this applies to you with your own CPA.

What this site is not

Physwealth is education from one physician who invests. It is not a financial-planning, wealth-management, tax or legal service, and I am not your adviser. For decisions about your own money, work with your own CPA, your own attorney, and a fiduciary financial adviser who is paid by you, not by a sponsor. Investments I mention are offered only by The Laager Group, through its offering documents. Full disclaimer